Media Freedom

I do love sidequests, and this has been one of my favourites over the last few years: Researching Media Freedom in a Time of Crisis: Academic study of the Global Campaign for Media Freedom., which allowed me to work with a really fun team based in the UK ( City, University of London, the University of East Anglia) the Philippines and Sudan.

Pleased to have contributed this report, Reviewing the Global Campaign for Media Freedom in the Philippines, where I evaluate the work of the Global Campaign for Media Freedom (GCMF) in the Philippines, as implemented  by the British Embassy Manila and its partners from 2019 to early 2021. Based on in-depth interviews with 30 respondents, it finds that the GCMF’s work was considered relevant and timely and that public statements condemning attacks on media freedom were positively received and reportedly helped with morale among media workers. However, it is unclear if these statement  contributed to their desired outcome of ‘raising the cost’ for those who attack media freedom. Moreover, very few local journalists and human rights workers are aware of the Campaign or the small grants it awarded.

The British Embassy in Manila is aware of these limitations; and it has been able to maximise reach and relevance despite modest resources. The report suggests, then, that this first set of activities in the Philippines generally fulfilled its function as a pilot diplomacy campaign despite pandemic-related restrictions. Going forward, sustained and substantial effectiveness will depend on how the GCMF and the British Embassy in Manila under the new FCDO will decide on what constitutes ‘effectiveness’ and how it should be measured.

This case study provides early evidence of how a global multilateral advocacy campaign gets translated at country level, and suggests lessons that can be learnt for future programming on media freedom – both in the Philippines and globally.

The Philippines evaluation fed into this broader report the team released in Estonia in February 2022, Reset Required? Evaluating the Media Freedom Coalition after its first two years, which has partially been reformed into a solid academic paper published in the top Communications journal. Not my discipline, but still pretty useful, one hopes:

Scott, M., Bunce, M., Myers, M., Fernandez, M.C., (2022) “Whose media freedom is being defended? Norm contestation in international media freedom campaigns” Journal of Communication. Volume 73, Issue 3.

Everything available at pressfreedom.co.uk.

PhD policy outputs so far

As I keep on saying to anyone who’d listen, a pandemic PhD is not something I’d wish on my worst enemy. Nevertheless, have been very clear since the beginning that the only way I would spend three++ years of my life on a project is to make sure that the effort addressed real needs on the ground.

Been v. fortunate to have gotten so much support, financially, spiritually, and otherwise. The PhD is primarily funded by the joint Philippine Department of Science and Technology – British Council’s joint Newton Agham scheme (incidentally here’s the #NewtonAgham closing anthology I recently edited, lol), with an explicit agreement that research outputs will be optimised for policy use. Given the sensitive nature of the topic (and the practical need to secure operational funding), activities in BARMM were facilitated through multiple research agreements signed between myself and relevant government institutions, INGOs, and CSOs, all of which have been cleared with DOST-SEI, the British Council, and the University of Cambridge Department of Land Economy. These agreements also facilitated fieldwork funding, data access, and collaborative partnerships with local research assistants and enumerators, many of whom are IDPs themselves. As of present writing, five partner organisations have signed a research and data sharing agreement granting me full permission to use anonymised data for scholarly publication as part of the PhD project, in academic journals and/or books, with full acknowledgment of the involved organisations. with the proviso that I would also produce policy papers ahead of the academic manuscript for immediate use.

So far, we’ve got at two publicly-available policy reports out the door, each corresponding to multiple chapters in the final PhD manuscript. Posting this here given recent requests, and in the spirit of full transparency.

Fernandez, M.C. (2023) Land rights, displacement, and transitional justice in the Bangsamoro: Insights from household-level mapping in Marawi City and Maguindanao. Davao City: Initiatives for International Dialogue.

Land dispossession is acknowledged as a root cause of historical and contemporary conflict in the Bangsamoro that must be jointly addressed by a wide range of stakeholders: the Government of the Philippines (GPH); the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF); the recently-created Parliament of the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (BARMM); relevant provincial, municipal, and barangay authorities; alongside traditional leaders, grassroots institutions, and clans. In response, this report summarizes findings from rapid community and household-level participatory and IDP-led mapping processes and dialogues conducted from late 2021 to mid-2022 in displaced neighborhoods in Marawi City, Lanao del Sur and South Upi and Firis Complex in Maguindanao. We present parcel-level evidence on the effects of protracted displacement and land tenure instability on Mranaw, Tëduray-Lambangian, and Maguindanaon internally-displaced persons (IDPs), along with concrete recommendations to aid in the resolution of land conflicts and dispossession, from the point-of-view of displaced residents themselves.

Download: https://iidnet.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/IID-Land-Research-updated.pdf

Fernandez, M.C. (2021) Land Governance as Moral Governance: Options for housing, land and property policy reform in the Bangsamoro transition. A Policy Brief. Cotabato City: Institute of Bangsamoro Studies with support from The Asia Foundation and USAID.

This document summarises the results of policy research undertaken by the Institute of Bangsamoro Studies (IBS) on the opportunities and constraints faced by the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (BARMM) related to housing, land and property (HLP) policy, with the goal of identifying executive and legislative actions that can be undertaken by the Bangsamoro Parliament in partnership with the Central Government, local communities and other actors.

Download: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YFfyK7FqlqBA6GQ5jAEydexS7ppLCwwM/view?usp=sharing

At least one or two more public reports should be out the door before the year is out, apart from the academic versions. Fingers crossed.

Miyakapira Ragon so Kapakambabakwit? A Review of Post-Marawi Crisis Rehabilitation and Reconstruction, 2017-2020 (Phindiyorobasaan sa Mranaw)

Kowa-kawn sa kopya “Miyakapira Ragon so Kapakambabakwit? A Review of Post-Marawi Crisis Rehabilitation and Reconstruction, 2017-2020 (Phindiyorobasaan sa Mranaw)” IMANTO DEN!

PDF: bit.ly/IlangTaongBakwitMranawPDF

Google Play Books: bit.ly/IlangTaongBakwitMranawGPB

May be an image of text that says "Miyakapira Ragon SO Kapakambabakwit? So Kiyasosona Milay, Kiyaperogorogoda ago Kiyapamandapati ko gii Katharagombalaya ago Kaphagompiyai sa Marawi ko Oriyan Kiyasanaat, 2017-20201 Olowan a Kiyamamesan (Key Findings) mapasad katharagombalaya pharoman Marawi oriyan tonganay inge Pilipinas baden ko bitiyara kamamanosiyai kapakasasarig ginawa. programa Marawi ago manga kiyabinasaan manga kakhapasad darepa oriyan kiyaipos miyakaphipira kiyathidawa inged kiyambonowai kapakambalingan tantara sa Pilipinas, Marawi tindoa gawii maminos 2022 pemans kakhapopos lalayon phekindod manga Misabap kiyalangga kapakambalingan pimbarang tantoa miyalanggay kapakabawi 56 pimbarang gobirno ko khisosophon probinsiya Bangon Marawi (TFBM) opisina gobirno Rodrigo Dutertesii rangkom shatimanena sangan adena ibebegay lawda (autonomous). Miyakapira Ragon Kapakambabakwit? 01"
May be an image of text that says "Urgent concerns for the Marawi Rehabilitation O OPEN DATA Available accessible data Marawi rehabilitat forms useful residents P COMPREHENSIVE ASSESSMENT and analy current spread IDPs ADEQUATE FUNDING Provide adeguate government Marawi Compensation SAFE, LIVABLE SHELTERS Address climate- and pandemic- related COMMUNITY-LED REHABILITATION UTILITY SERVICES Reconstruct essential infrastructure electricity, LIVELIHOOD Provide economically livelihood and microfinancing options EDUCATION Reconstruct schools lended students learning systems ENVIRONMENT Address the environmental impacts Lanao watershed 16 Miyakapira Ragon so Kapakambabakwit?"
May be an image of text that says "mipantag kabokaan assessment) kabotawanan manga mambebetad mapakalawlad inged kiyalanggay madakel manga inged ilmo (datar elu patot madakel manga ago panagontamanko manga kambalaya manga ogop/ panabang manga AMAD MANGA THOTOL DATA). malebod rakes magaan okita ago amad mipantag katharagombalaya mala-i osba pagtaw maginged SERBISYO KHAWSEBAAN Mapakalawlads PAMANDAPAT manga serbisyo paka- korente, telepeno ago nggolalan manga pamandapatan somosonged kiniparak manga analysis),a kapapantagan bakwit (economically para -apas manga Mranaw pamirak pondo Compensation KATHONTO MAPIYA (EDUCATION). manga eskwelaan PAMIKIRAN TAWN, KAPAGINETAW BABALINGAN system) estudyante masangor kathontot miyanga-rarambita manga manga mosim (pandemic) babalingan tatap mapontarya somanga mapiya meliliyotaleb (Lake watershed) (COMMUNITY-LED madakel Ragon Kapakambabakwit?"

Giyangkai a piyaka-kampet a osayan, phindiyorobasaan ago initogalin sa basa a Mranaw i Tirmizy E. Abdullah, Ph.D., na miyapento ago miyapakarayag iyan so manga olowan a kiyamamesan ago so manga mosawer (recommendations) phoon ko asal a miya-amad a thotol a inisorat i Ica Fernandez ago piyaki-bembar a INCITEGov ko October 2021. (Ilayangka sa: https://www.facebook.com/106515049435895/posts/4604566522964036).

Sii ko taman a kakekenalawn ko October 2021, na 17,060 a manga pamilya na kasasagadan iran so karamosayan ko kiyalanggay o kapakambabakwit / kapakapago-oyag sabap ko kiyasanaat a Marawi ko 2017 (2017 Marawi siege). Liyo roo pen, na o da a Marawi Compensation bill na madakel ko manga bakwit / maginged na di iran maphembalay sharoman so manga walay iran, taman imanto na da pen maka-apas ago matanto giyangkoto a kitab. Giyai i manga ped ko diden mipheshomala a manga awida-akal ko gii katharagombalaya sa Marawi (Marawi rehabilitation) a paliyogat so masambot a kabegi ron imoleng ago panagontaman, mlagid den so kapapantagan a manga olowan, opisyal, ago bebegan sa kapaar sa baba (local) ago poro (national) a gobirno ago so pen so makaphiphikir a pamangped sa politika a manga kandidato a popontariyaan iran a kapamakataban iran sa kadato ago posisyon ko May 2022 a kapheshasamili sa manga olowan / eleksyon (May 2022 polls). O antonaa i mapheniniyat ago mapipikir a okit o manga kandidato ko kasangora iran a panagontaman sangkai a manga awida-akal mipantag ko kamamanosiyai, kalilinding, kasisiyapa ko pagtaw a ped ko manga plataporma iran na nganin a taralbi a katitikayan ago maiinengka o pagtaw ago maginged.